A Parent Confusion

submitted by: Jason

*I did an interview for American Baby Magazine regarding our parenting technique. We are the only ones in the article that spank. Unforunately, they describe me as ‘pro-spanking’ and (as expected) is a little out of context and makes me sound like a freak. I would say, more acurately, that I simply believe that spanking is effective when used properly. Click here to read it.*

After having two kids, and with one more on the way, I have been thinking again. One huge lesson that shocked me into reality was how much of my children’s future depends on what I do with them in their formative years. It scares me to realize that most of who they are—disposition, learning capacity, emotional strength, personality etc.—is determined by the time they are FIVE years old! That doesn’t mean that things are set in stone from that point forward, but it does mean that we need to live with a constant sense of urgency. We need to make our best efforts in those prime years to raise the next generation to be ready for life. We need to use those years to our, and ultimately their, advantage. But as I have observed, and spoken to, many families I have come to realize another disturbing truth. Just because someone is a parent doesn’t mean they are parenting.

Have you observed this as well? You’re in a restaurant and the three year old at the table next to you is screaming uncontrollably, tears and all. The parents apply a systematic approach. They plea, “Do you want your toy?” More screaming. They move on to, “Do you want your juice?” Still more screaming. They beg, “How about a cookie?” More screaming with the added bonus of the above items becoming airborne. And then they lay down the law, “If you don’t stop we’re going to leave the restaraunt!” Or maybe you’ve seen the child coming out of Target as you’re going in. He’s flailing about yelling, “I hate you!” because he hasn’t gotten the toy he wanted. One of my favorites was when I saw a child being very disrespectful to his mother. After being told and warned several times she finally responded with, “That’s it! No ice cream for a month!”

Sadly, these situations are all too common. In fact, they are more common than not. And what makes matters worse is these approaches are not effective and are very unhealthy. I love my children enough to nurture them, but to also discipline them effectively. I want them to be ready for life because life is not easy…

A child needs structure and discipline that is consistent and clearly defined. They need to be able to predict the outcome of their actions, both positive and negative. Also, those consequences need to make sense. A child doesn’t care if you leave a restaurant. And when you give them that kind of control you’ve already lost. Talking back should have immediate, severe consequences. And taking away ice cream for a month? That’s a joke and not an effective consequence for not listening. A child will never respect a parent that ‘dishes’ out these kinds of consequences. I think there are many affective ways to deal with these situations. They may sound old-school but they are effective: rude words=soap in mouth, blatant defiance and screaming=spank (That’s right! I said it…take them out to the car and deal with their defiance. Afterwards, make sure to embrace them and tell them how much you love them.)

I don’t claim to be an expert but I have read thousands of pages on parenting because I desperately desire to do a good job. If you are a parent please put a plan together and make sure mom and dad are on the same page. Becoming a parent is a natural process but parenting doesn’t come naturally. It is hard work and you will not always see the results of your efforts. But children need to be nurtured and effectively disciplined. It is not enough to ‘wing-it’ as a parent. Remember, you are trusted by God with shaping this individual into the person they will become. And who they become will be largely based on how they grow up. Just think about yourself and your past. For the sake of your kids do some reading and ask some people you respect.

Let me be perfectly clear, if you are a parent you have to…parent.

If you like this post then please consider subscribing to our full feed RSS
6 responses to 'A Parent Confusion'
Join the fray. Read through the following comments and add to the discussion at the end.
Tom
April 15, 2007 at 2:56 am

I’ve never actually heard of anyone excercising this ‘soap in their mouth’ idea.  Are we talking about ACTUALLY making them keep a bar of soap in their mouth?  I’m assuming that this must taste awful.

Jason
April 15, 2007 at 7:54 am

No, I don’t actually mean keeping it in there. Just a brief touch of a little soap. That way they get the hint of the bad taste and you (as a parent) can create a moment to each and equate their rude words with that taste.

We have actually begun using something a little more effective. We call it “Yucky Juice”. It’s basically a revolting mixture of vinegar, worcester sauce, lime juice etc. We squirt a little in their mouth when these incidents occur (after a warning).

The response from them? “Yuck!” Hence, the name. That’s we use the sauce to explain their attitude and words they use: the awful taste is how their words feel to others when they talk like that or talk back.

Good question! Thanks so much.

Jason

Tom
April 15, 2007 at 10:14 pm

I just read the linked article.  Personally, I don’t get why everyone is so uptight about spanking.  It has it’s place and does serve some good, I don’t care what others say.  But if you rely on it solely to enforce discipline, you’re kidding yourself.  I’m tired of popular parenting articles that jump on current fads; it’s so very obvious.

Jason
April 16, 2007 at 5:57 am

I totally agree. The article was very weak in it talked about spanking. The parents all regretted doing it but notice they didn’t use it right. It seemed like they would lose their temper and then start spanking. Of course that doesn’t work and leaves you with a deep sense of guilt as a parent.

Also, do these parents ever think that there kids go so far because they will not learn how to learn and incorporate spanking in their discipline plan? In other words, the kids push the limits so far and so much because there is not a serious consequence? They don’t know what true limits are.

Think about the generations that were spanked. They did amazing things and won hard wars. Now, I know some of those family techniques were excessive, but those children learned a range of limits through a variety of disciplines and structure.

Today? We call spanking corporal punsihment and expect kids to grow up learning true limits as children that will develop them into mature, well-adjusted, disciplined adults.

Spanking also does something to me, as a parent, like nothing else. It forces me to examine my heart every time. To ask myself if I am disciplining my children for behavior that I, myself, display or have inadvertantly taught them? It is the only form of discipline that does that. I cannot dance around and avoid my personal issues when I choose to spank. It forces me to look at myself.

Thanks Tom.

David
April 23, 2007 at 2:30 pm

We have chosen not to spank.  I was raised with spanking and she wasn’t.

What has mostly driven our decision is the way the daycare provider handles discipline and the fact we have seen it work.

I find we are dealing with basic human emotions.  To me, guilt which should be followed by reflection of our actions which caused the guilt is the driver in changing a behavior.  Upon understanding of the consequence of an action, the individual chooses not to behave in this manner.

I have seen it work as my daughter doesn’t want to feel unhappy because she did something wrong.  We often discuss right and wrong and actions that accordingly are right or wrong.

I would prefer my daughter chooses not to do something because she feels it’s wrong rather than not do it because of fear.

I do respect you did your research and have a plan in place… it’s miles ahead of most of the parents I meet…i.e. the lunch story is so real


April 25, 2007 at 1:04 pm

Jason,

I agree with your article and position fully.  We did a lot of research and decided to spank on occasions (not very often) to ensure our boys understood and connected bad behavior with spanking (cause & effect).

Your example of a on the child in a restaurant has played out many times before and I’ve been appalled by the parents lack of consideration of others. 

We also used the soap in the mouth when our children used foul language or were disrespectful.  It worked wonderfully for our youngest who had the loose mouth tendencies.

Our boys are well behaved and respectful.  We can venture to restaurants without worrying of a melt-down or being embarassed.

We haven’t had to spank a child in months.

Bravo to your article and your closing on the importance of being a parent!  If everyone took 1/2 the interest you have in your children, the world would be so much better.

Keep up the great articles!

johnny

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.

Subscribe to DadBloggers

Subscribe to our RSS feed

or subscribe via email

Recent Posts Recent Comments

Link Love

Link us and we'll link you back

Tales of a Newbie Dad
The Philosopher Dad
Bringing Mikayla Home
My Lil' Goombas
The Life of a Father of Five
Paternal Life
Dad 2.0
Rockin' the Kids' Music World